

Since I'm snowed in, from an "early" storm (it was supposed to hit tomorrow), I'm reading, and Carl Swenlin caught my eye with this article on his monthly PMO, Price Momentum Osc,
http://www.financialsense.com/editorials/swenlin/2009/1204.html , so I went into doddling mode.
TradeStation doesn't have a PMO, but, it does have a P, as in Price OSC, and an MO, as in Momentum, and when you put the two of them on the chart, they come up with a similar look to it, the MO is at the bottom, with the P above that, and then a price chart of the INDU, since I can only get historical data on the INDU back to the 1920's, and not the SPX, so hence I used the INDU. Also, Dr. McHugh commented in one of his advertisements today, about his "Long Term" trend indicator, which is a cross of the 20/40 Month moving average's. I also inserted a 10 Month moving average, which is a study of a few market technician's, who claim it is a great long term moving average to use, to determine if we are in bear or bull markets. Personally, I find that a cross of the 10 month average, the GREEN line, over/under the 20 Month moving average, the BLUE line, is a better cross over idea than the 20/40 month cross over, just my personal opinion.
The reason I'm bringing this whole thing up, is because the "P" indicator is doing a cross over of the ZERO line as I write, which is the first cross to the up side, since the end of the last bear market in 03'. By the by, I should bring up that the bottom chart is the current chart, the TOP chart is the 1920-30's, the next chart down is the 70's, and the third chart down is the 80's.
The next thing I did, was draw a RED VERTICAL line, during all those periods in the chart's, in which the "P" crossed to the up side, above the ZERO line, following significant drop's, or some times called, Bear Markets. I found the results kind of interesting.
One interesting thing, was the current angle of the slope, of the 20 month MA, there's only three other period's close to this severe of a down angle, 1931 into 1933, 1971, and 1974 into 1975. I also looked at the "Spread", between the 10ma and the 20ma, when the "P" crossed the ZERO line, we currently have the largest spread ever, but of course, we also have the HIGHEST price ever, so you'd have to do a percent difference, which I'm not inclined to take the time to do, bottom line, is they are all pretty much close to the same thing.
Despite my over all BEARISH funnymental out look, as I think that the current period we are in, IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT THAN ANY OTHER PERIOD, I want to look at some conclusions, based on as much OBJECTIVITY, that I can do. Number one, the "MO", always crosses the ZERO line BEFORE the "P", and before the cross over of the 10 and 20 ma's, and as such, I consider it a pretty interesting demarkation point of bear and bull markets. Number two, when the "P", or, if you want to use the better indicator, the "MO", cross over the ZERO line, we ALWAYS get an extended period of positive prices. Well, ok, not always, but the periods when it didn't work, were in "FLAT" periods, when price was moving side ways, not in severe up and down movements. Here are a few time frames, of how many months we got, of positive price action, after the "P", crossed above the ZERO line:
1933: 9 months of rally, followed by a decent 6 month pull back, leading to new highs in 1937
1939: Lousy, side ways for 17 mo., before a significant pull back into the bottom in 1942
1943: 6 months up, a very slight pull back, then up into 1946 highs
1963: flat for 2 months, then a HUGE run into 1966 highs
1967: Up only 2 months, then a six month decent pull back, then new highs in 1968
1971: Up for only 3 months, then a seven month decent pull back, then new highs in 1973
1975: IMMEDIATE 3 month pull back, very slight, then new highs in 1976
1978: A flat period, that led to new highs in 1981
1982: 6 more months of rally, into a 1983 high, pull back in 84', followed by the bull market into 2000 (with a little blip in 87' and 98')
2003: 5 more months of rallies into the 04' high, followed by a lengthy, gradual pull back,which led to the 2007 highs.
A couple of observations, number one, you could pick up a LOT of change, by using the "MO" rather than the "P", as you pick up a minimum of TWO months, and a maximum of FOUR months of extra gains. Number two, in just a casual observation of the numbers above, we "USUALLY" get additional gains for two to six months after the cross over, accept for 37' and 75', and possibly the little flat period in 78', BUT IN ALL CASE'S, we get another PULL BACK, before making new highs, so the odd's are very great, that, yea, we may continue the rally for another six month's, but the odd's are ALMOST 100%, that we have another pull back coming, before going to new highs after that pull back.
Here's some of the rough numbers of the percentage gain when we break above the ZERO line, and then the percentage of the pull back:
33': 25 - 20
39': (41%)
43': 16 - 14
63': 2 - 7
67': 6 - 14
71': 10 - 18
75': 0 - 12
78': 25 - 25
82: 30 - 18
03': 14 - 11
There was some interesting observations when doing the numbers above, and it was not the averaging of the numbers, but if you take out the dump in 39', the average gain was "about" 14%, and the average pull back was "about" 15.5%, so the pull back, in GENERAL, is larger than the gains you make after the break above the ZERO line.
The most interesting thing I found was that in EVERY case, EVERY ONE, 100% of the time, at some point, we came back and tested the bar that broke out over the ZERO line, OR, in five cases, at some point we went LOWER than the break out bar. I'm excluding 1939 of course, as we never went up off the bar, although we came back in 10 months and double topped at that bar, before heading into the abyss in 1942.
Now, what I want to do, is throw out all the years, that we DID NOT rally straight up, to where we got the cross over of the "P", IE, I want to see what my odd's are, only from the patterns that most closely resemble the one we are in now. I'm almost hesitant to use 1933, for as you can see, we actually had a rally off the 32' bottom, that was followed by a 41% bear market into the higher low in 1933, before rallying into the 1933 cross of the ZERO line, hmmmmm, it doesn't really fit the pattern. I'm also going to throw out 78', we did not rally into that cross over.
The rally after the 37' bear market led to a four year bear market almost from the bar that made the "P" cross.
The 43' cross was "tested" in 10 months, and then led to basically a bull market into the 62' bear.
The 63' cross led to an immediate two month, 7 percent correction, that led to all time highs in 66', however, we came back and broke that bar in 1970.
The 67' cross had a one month rally, then pulled back 14% for six months, before making all time highs in 69'.
The 71' cross rallied for two months, before a 18%, six month pull back, that then led to all time highs in 73'.
The 75' cross had an immediate 3 month, 12% pull back, before rally to all time highs in 76'.
The 82' cross led to the bull market of 82-2000, however, we came back to test the cross over bar 19 months later.
The 03' cross rallied for four months, then came back and tested the cross over bar 12 months later.
So, just for my own personal perspective, I DO NOT, have to buy the market here, at some point down the road, there is almost a 100% chance, I will see these prices again. I could miss out on a 25-30% rally here, it happened three times before. There's a five in eight chance, or 63%, that once this bar completes this month, we will have a pull back with in two to three months, that will go down any where from 11 to 25% (possibly MORE this time, if it is indeed, DIFFERENT). Once the correction ends, where ever that may be, and, we go back up and take out what ever high we make after this current cross over, there is a 100% chance, that we will make new all time highs after that.
The major fly in the ointment (there always is), is that we had THREE TESTS, of the cross over bar, two of them, 34' and 84', NEVER saw those numbers again (YET!), the other, 04', had a three year rally to new all time highs, although we broke it the past year. The GOOD part about those TESTS, is that it took a YEAR, or MORE, before the test was made, IE, we showed some reasonable strength, with a fairly mild pull back into the retest, and "should" be, identifiable. If we don't start a major pull back IMMEDIATELY after this month, or by the latest February or March, then we are probably in the long drawn out retest senario.
Just a little note, the "MO" has a small hook on it right now.